Trucking insurance premiums are influenced by numerous risk factors that insurers carefully evaluate when underwriting policies. Understanding these factors helps carriers and owner-operators manage their risk exposure and potentially reduce insurance costs. In 2025, certain risks continue to drive premium increases across the industry.
1. Claims History and Loss Ratio
Your claims history is the single biggest factor affecting your insurance rates. Insurers analyze your loss ratio—the relationship between premiums paid and claims filed. A high loss ratio indicates you're a risky client, leading to premium increases or non-renewal. Conversely, a clean claims history can earn you significant discounts.
How to manage it: Focus on accident prevention, implement safety programs, and avoid filing small claims that you can afford to pay out of pocket.
2. Driver Safety Scores and MVRs
Driver behavior directly impacts insurance rates. Insurers review Motor Vehicle Records (MVRs) for violations, accidents, and driving history. CSA scores and Safety Measurement System (SMS) data also factor heavily into underwriting decisions.
How to manage it: Hire experienced drivers with clean records, provide ongoing safety training, and monitor driver performance through telematics.
3. Vehicle Maintenance Records
Poorly maintained equipment increases accident risk due to mechanical failures. Insurers view comprehensive maintenance programs as a sign of a well-run operation and may offer discounts for fleets with documented preventative maintenance schedules.
How to manage it: Keep detailed maintenance logs, address repairs promptly, and retire aging equipment before it becomes a liability.
4. Cargo Type and Commodities Hauled
Certain cargo types carry higher risk and therefore higher premiums. Hazmat, high-value electronics, pharmaceuticals, and perishable goods require specialized handling and face greater theft or liability exposure.
How to manage it: Diversify your freight profile if possible, implement cargo security measures, and ensure you have appropriate coverage limits for high-value loads.
5. Operating Radius and Geographic Territory
Long-haul interstate operations typically cost more to insure than local or regional routes. Urban areas with heavy traffic and higher accident rates also increase premiums. Additionally, operating in high-theft or high-litigation states can drive up costs.
How to manage it: If you can operate regionally or locally, premiums may be lower. Avoid high-risk corridors when possible.
6. Company Age and Experience
New entrant carriers pay significantly more for insurance due to lack of operating history and higher failure rates. Seasoned carriers with proven track records enjoy lower rates.
How to manage it: New carriers should expect higher premiums initially. Build a strong safety record, maintain continuous coverage, and work toward lower rates over time.
7. Safety Technology and Telematics
Carriers using dash cams, collision avoidance systems, electronic logging devices (ELDs), and telematics often receive premium discounts. These technologies demonstrate proactive risk management and can exonerate drivers in disputed claims.
How to manage it: Invest in safety technology and work with insurers who recognize and reward its use.
8. Deductible Amounts
Higher deductibles lower premiums but increase out-of-pocket costs per claim. The right balance depends on your cash flow and risk tolerance.
How to manage it: Analyze your claims frequency and financial reserves to determine the optimal deductible.
9. Business Credit and Financial Stability
Some insurers use business credit scores as part of their underwriting process. Strong financials signal stability and responsibility, potentially lowering premiums.
How to manage it: Pay bills on time, manage debt responsibly, and maintain healthy business credit.
10. Regulatory Compliance and CSA Scores
FMCSA violations, failed inspections, and poor CSA scores increase premiums. Insurers view non-compliant carriers as higher risk.
How to manage it: Stay current on DOT regulations, address violations immediately, and maintain clean CSA scores.
Final Thoughts
While some risk factors are outside your control, many can be actively managed to reduce insurance costs. Focus on safety, compliance, equipment maintenance, and building a strong claims history. Over time, these efforts pay dividends in lower premiums and better insurer partnerships.
Want to reduce your trucking insurance rates?
Guild Road Insurance Agency LLC works with carriers to identify risk reduction opportunities and find competitive rates. Contact us for a personalized insurance review.
Get a Quote